What is the Difference Between Safety Data Sheets (SDS) and COSHH Assessments?

Article Written by:

Meyyappan M

Created On:

November 27, 2025

What is the Difference Between Safety Data Sheets (SDS) and COSHH Assessments?

Table of Contents:

A safety auditor walks into a facility, and the plant manager proudly points to a thick, dusty binder on the shelf. "We are fully compliant," they say. "We have an SDS for every chemical in the building."

That binder might be full of data, but possessing data is not the same as managing risk.

Many maintenance leaders fall into the trap of thinking that holding the documentation equals having a safety culture. It doesn't. While the Safety Data Sheet (SDS) provides the ingredients of danger, the COSHH Assessment provides the recipe for safety. If you want to move from simply storing paper to actively protecting your team—and avoiding the massive reactive maintenance costs associated with accidents—you need to understand how these two documents differ and how they work together.

What are Safety Data Sheets (SDS)?

Think of an SDS (formerly known as MSDS) as a passport for a chemical product. It travels with the chemical from the manufacturer to your facility.

An SDS is a technical document provided by the supplier. Its job is to tell you exactly what the chemical is and what it is capable of doing in a generic sense. It does not know your factory, your ventilation system, or your technicians.  

Key Contents of an SDS:

  • Hazards: Is it flammable? Toxic? Corrosive?
  • Composition: What specific ingredients are inside?
  • Emergency Measures: What should you do if it is swallowed or splashed in the eyes?
  • Storage Requirements: Technical specs like "Store below 25°C" or "Keep away from moisture."
  • The Critical Distinction: An SDS is static. It lists the hazards of the substance in its pure form. It doesn't know if you are using a single drop in a test tube or a 50-gallon drum in a confined space.

What are COSHH Assessments?

COSHH stands for Control of Substances Hazardous to Health. While SDS is a document about a product, a COSHH assessment is a document about a task.  

This is a legal framework (originating in the UK but used as a gold standard for risk assessment globally) that you, the employer, must create. It bridges the gap between the chemical's theoretical danger and your real-world reality.

The 5-Step COSHH Logic:

  • Identify: Which substances are being used?
  • Evaluate: Who is exposed? For how long? In what environment?
  • Prevent/Control: Can we swap this chemical for a safer one? If not, do we need extraction fans or specific PPE?
  • Implement: Putting these rules into the daily workflow.
  • Monitor: Regularly checking if the controls are actually working.

Key Differences Between SDS and COSHH Assessments

It is easy to confuse these two documents because they both deal with chemical safety, but confusing them can leave a massive gap in your risk management strategy. To understand the difference, you have to look at intent and application.

Here is the breakdown of how they differ in the real world:

1. The Source: Who Writes It?

  • Safety Data Sheet (SDS): This is written by the chemical manufacturer or supplier. It is an external document. The author is a chemist who knows everything about the substance but nothing about your factory, your employees, or your equipment.
  • COSHH Assessment: This is written by you (the employer) or your designated safety officer. It is an internal document. The author must be someone who understands the specific working environment where the chemical will be used.

2. The Focus: The Product vs. The Task

  • SDS Focuses on the Product: An SDS describes the chemical in a "vacuum." For example, it will tell you that a specific degreaser is corrosive. It provides a generic baseline of hazards assuming the chemical is in its pure form.
  • COSHH Focuses on the Task: The assessment looks at the activity. It asks: How are we using this degreaser? Are we wiping it with a rag (low risk), or are we spraying it at high pressure (high respiratory risk)? The assessment changes based on the method of use, even if the chemical remains the same.

3. The Content: Properties vs. Controls

  • SDS Content: It lists hazard classifications (e.g., "Toxic if inhaled"), chemical composition, and physical properties like boiling points and flash points. It gives generic advice like "Use in a well-ventilated area."
  • COSHH Content: It translates that generic advice into specific instructions. instead of saying "well-ventilated," a COSHH assessment might specify, "Must be used inside Fume Hood #4 with the sash at 18 inches." It details the exact PPE, exposure times, and emergency procedures relevant to that specific spot on the plant floor.

4. The Objective: Information vs. Decision Making

  • SDS is Passive (Information): Think of the SDS as a reference library. It sits there waiting to be read. It is passive data that informs you of potential dangers.
  • COSHH is Active (Operational): The COSHH assessment is a decision-making tool. It is the result of analyzing the data and deciding how to act. It acts as the operational "permit" that allows the work to proceed safely.

Practical Use: How SDS and COSHH Work Together

You cannot have a valid COSHH assessment without the data from the SDS. Here is what the workflow looks like in a high-functioning maintenance department:

  • Product Arrives: The warehouse team receives the chemical and saves the SDS.
  • Data Extraction: The safety lead reads the SDS to find Hazard Codes (e.g., "Causes severe skin burns").
  • Observation: You look at the workspace. Is the area ventilated? Is the technician trained?

    • Drafting: You create the COSHH assessment.
    • The SDS says: "Wear respiratory protection."
  • The COSHH Assessment specifies: "Technician must wear a full-face respirator with A2P3 filters because the task takes 40 minutes in a confined space."

The Consequence of the Gap If you rely only on the SDS, your technician might wear a basic dust mask for a vapor hazard because the SDS was too vague. This leads to health issues, which leads to sick leave, which ultimately drives up downtime costs and disrupts your maintenance strategy.

Best Practices for Managing SDS and COSHH Assessments

Managing hundreds of chemicals and their associated risk assessments on paper is a recipe for failure. In the era of Industry 4.0, your safety documentation should be as dynamic as your operations.

1. Currency and Version Control

SDSs update whenever regulations (like REACH) change. If you are holding an SDS from 2010, you are non-compliant.

The Solution: Use Inventory Management tools (like those in Cryotos) to track the lifecycle of your chemicals. You can set automated reminders to check for updated SDS versions from suppliers.

2. Accessibility at the Point of Work

Don't lock safety sheets in a manager's office. If a technician is repairing a hydraulic line at 2:00 AM, they need safety info now, not tomorrow morning.

The Solution: Leverage Mobile Accessibility. With Cryotos CMMS, you can attach the specific SDS PDF and the COSHH instructions directly to the Work Order. The technician scans a QR code on the asset or chemical container and sees the safety data instantly on their phone.  

3. Integrated Safety Workflows

Safety shouldn't be an afterthought; it should be a gatekeeper.

The Solution: Use Workflow Automation. You can configure your CMMS so that a technician cannot mark a Work Order as "In Progress" until they have digitally signed the specific safety checklist or Permit to Work associated with those chemicals.

4. Reducing Reactive Costs

Poor chemical safety leads to accidents, spills, and corrosion damage. These incidents force you into "firefighting" mode.

The Impact: By integrating safety data into your preventive maintenance schedules (e.g., checking ventilation systems for chemical storage), you avoid the massive reactive maintenance costs associated with emergency shutdowns and regulatory fines.

Conclusion

Compliance requires both the "ingredients" and the "recipe." The Safety Data Sheet provides the essential facts, but the COSHH assessment translates those facts into safe actions on the shop floor.

Safety isn't about paperwork; it's about people. The relationship between SDS and COSHH is the foundation of a safe chemical culture. When you get this right, you don't just improve safety scores; you improve asset lifecycle management by ensuring chemicals are used and stored correctly, preserving both your equipment and your team.

Want to Try Cryotos CMMS Today? Lets Connect!
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Related Post
No items found.